House Speaker Mike Johnson Promises Massive Overhaul of Affordable Care Act If Trump Wins

Source: YouTube

House Speaker Mike Johnson has vowed to make a “massive reform” of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) a priority in the first 100 days if Republicans win control of the White House and Congress in 2024. Johnson’s comments, made at a campaign event in Pennsylvania, signal the GOP’s ongoing push to overhaul the ACA, which they view as an example of government overreach. While Johnson’s plan includes an extensive “free market” approach to health care reform, former President Donald Trump’s campaign has distanced itself from Johnson’s statements, underscoring internal divisions within the GOP on the future of the ACA.

Johnson’s Focus on “Massive Reform” Over Repeal

Since its enactment in 2010, the ACA, commonly known as “Obamacare,” has faced strong opposition among Republicans. The GOP sees the ACA as an example of excessive federal involvement, arguing it raises health care costs and restricts market freedom. By mandating coverage requirements, critics argue, the ACA limits flexibility in coverage options and imposes higher premiums. Republicans have long advocated for a health care model that minimizes government intervention, allowing private insurers more autonomy to offer varied, competitive plans suited to different needs and budgets.

At the campaign event, Johnson emphasized that health care reform would be central to the GOP’s legislative agenda if they gain power. While he didn’t specify what the overhaul would entail, Johnson called for less government involvement in the health care system and proposed returning to a more “doctor-patient relationship” without what he termed unnecessary government oversight. He underscored his intention to “take a blowtorch to the regulatory state,” reducing federal controls that he claims drive up costs and limit access to quality care. However, Johnson’s proposal stops short of an outright repeal, instead calling for “massive reform” to align the ACA more closely with Republican principles.

Trump Campaign Distances Itself from Johnson’s Promise

Though Johnson’s remarks have reignited health care reform discussions, Trump’s campaign was quick to clarify that Johnson’s ACA overhaul stance “is not President Trump’s policy position.” Previously, Trump sought to repeal the ACA but faced significant public backlash. Now, his campaign suggests retaining the ACA’s existing benefits unless a superior alternative is available. Trump’s position recognizes the ACA’s deep entrenchment in the health care system, acknowledging the potential political risks of drastic changes, especially after past attempts led to setbacks for the GOP.

This cautious approach reflects lessons learned from the 2017 repeal efforts, which ultimately failed in the Senate and contributed to Republicans losing control of the House in 2018. Trump’s campaign appears to favor gradual adjustments focused on cost savings and efficiency over the broader reforms Johnson is advocating.

The Potential Impact of an ACA Overhaul

Despite Trump’s reserved stance, Johnson’s vision for reform is gaining traction among GOP leaders. Johnson mentioned that a group of Republican physicians, the GOP Doctors Caucus, is currently exploring ideas to streamline health care by minimizing federal controls. These proposals could allow insurers greater flexibility in designing plans, potentially reducing premiums but also risking the elimination of popular protections for preexisting conditions and essential health benefits.

​​The concept of allowing more flexibility has appeal among certain voters, particularly those who want options that suit specific health care needs. For instance, GOP leaders argue that families with generally low medical costs should have the choice to purchase low-premium plans without extensive coverage. However, critics warn that minimizing coverage mandates could weaken the ACA’s protections, especially for individuals with chronic illnesses, leaving them with higher premiums or fewer options.

As the election nears, Johnson’s comments have renewed debates over the ACA’s future. Should the GOP win, the direction of reform remains uncertain, with Johnson and Trump potentially representing two distinct paths. For many Americans, the ACA’s future could mean retaining core protections with cost adjustments or facing a complete overhaul in favor of a more market-driven model.

Do you agree with Johnson’s plan to massively overhaul the Affordable Care Act? Tell us what you think about the ACA.